Up, down & out : Tracking the trends - US golf course rankings
Traditional gains
A change of just a fraction of a point can move a course up or down 20 spots. Older courses tended to gain from a small change to the calculation of bonus Tradition points, which award more to older courses than newer ones. So Milwaukee Country Club jumped to 50th from 72nd and Valley Club of Montecito made the biggest leap, moving to 59th from 88th.
Mountain declines
Starting this year, we no longer automatically award 2 bonus points for walking, but adjust that number according to the walkability of each course. Every course that allows walking lost a fraction of its bonus from two years ago, because no course is perfectly walkable, but mountainous courses saw the biggest drops. Colorado’s Castle Pines went to 74th from 46th, and Sanctuary moved to 89th from 48th.
A veteran passing
Every season sees the loss of at least one veteran 100 Greatest member. Two years ago it was Aronimink. This time it’s Saucon Valley (Grace) in Pennsylvania, previously on every ranking since 1971 and No. 96 in 1999. Its members should take heart, though. Aronimink returned to the 100 Greatest this year after a two-year absence.
Hollow Pumpkin
Not the reviews they wanted
Architect Pete Dye’s Oak Tree Golf Club in Oklahoma (No. 92 in 1999) and his namesake Pete Dye Golf Club in West Virginia (formerly No. 97) dropped off, but one of his new courses, Whistling Straits in Wisconsin, made the list. Tom Fazio gained two, but despite his recent revisions to Edgewood Tahoe Golf Club in Nevada (No. 99 in ‘99), it failed to remain on this year’s list. Two former Fazio associates also saw their works drop from the 100 Greatest: Mike Strantz’ Royal New Kent Golf Club in Virginia (formerly No. 84) and Dana Fry’s Naples National Golf Club (formerly No. 100) in Florida.
Two of designer Rees Jones’ courses dropped off: Haig Point (Calibogue) in South Carolina (No. 76 in 1999) and Ocean Forest in Georgia (No. 91). His Atlantic Golf Club in New York is No. 100, the same spot held by Bethpage Black in 1997 before it dropped off the list two years ago. But after a Jones redesign, the Long Island public course jumps back on the list at No. 46.
RELATED ARTICLE: State rankings: Pocket Planner
Our Best Courses in Each State survey runs concurrently with our ranking of America’s 100 Greatest Golf Courses.
To see how the courses in your state fared, please see the special Pocket Planner supplement attached in this issue between pages xx and xx.
For a complete look at our survey, please see www.golfdigest.com/ 100greatest.